Wzór konstruktora: który wariant jest preferowany? [Zamknięte]
Przeglądałem książkę Skuteczna Java i tworzyłem notatki do mojego przyszłego odniesienia, natknąłem się na Wzór Buildera.
Cóż, zrozumiałem, co to jest i jak należy go używać. W tym procesie stworzyłem dwie przykładowe odmiany wzoru budowniczego.
Potrzebowałbym pomocy w spisaniu różnic i korzyści, jakie każdy z nich ma? Cóż, z pewnością to zauważyłemExample 1
eksponuje mniej metod, mniej restrykcyjne i bardziej ogólne, pozwalając na bardziej elastyczne wykorzystanie.
Proszę wskazać inne rzeczy, które przegapiłem?
Przykład 1
package item2;
/**
* @author Sudhakar Duraiswamy
*
*/
public class Vehicle {
private String type;
private int wheels;
interface Builder<T>{
public T build();
}
public static class CarBuilder implements Builder<Vehicle>{
private String type;
private int wheels;
CarBuilder createVehicle(){
this.type= "Car";
return this;
}
CarBuilder addWheels(int wheels){
this.wheels = wheels;
return this;
}
public Vehicle build(){
Vehicle v = new Vehicle();
v.type = type;
v.wheels = wheels;
return v;
}
}
public static class TruckBuilder implements Builder<Vehicle>{
private String type;
private int wheels;
TruckBuilder createVehicle(){
this.type= "Truck";
return this;
}
TruckBuilder addWheels(int wheels){
this.wheels = wheels;
return this;
}
public Vehicle build(){
Vehicle v = new Vehicle();
v.type = type;
v.wheels = wheels;
return v;
}
}
public Vehicle(){
}
public static void main(String[] args) {
//This builds a car with 4 wheels
Vehicle car = new Vehicle.CarBuilder().createVehicle().addWheels(4).build();
//THis builds a Truck with 10 wheels
Vehicle truck = new Vehicle.TruckBuilder().createVehicle().addWheels(10).build();
}
}
Przykład 2
package item2;
/**
* @author Sudhakar Duraiswamy
*
*/
public class Vehicle2 {
private String type;
private int wheels;
interface Builder<T>{
public T build();
public String getType();
public int getWheels() ;
}
public static class CarBuilder implements Builder<Vehicle2>{
private String type;
private int wheels;
public String getType() {
return type;
}
public int getWheels() {
return wheels;
}
CarBuilder createVehicle(){
this.type= "Car";
return this;
}
CarBuilder addWheels(int wheels){
this.wheels = wheels;
return this;
}
public Vehicle2 build(){
return new Vehicle2(this);
}
}
public static class TruckBuilder implements Builder<Vehicle2>{
private String type;
private int wheels;
public String getType() {
return type;
}
public int getWheels() {
return wheels;
}
TruckBuilder createVehicle(){
this.type= "Truck";
return this;
}
TruckBuilder addWheels(int wheels){
this.wheels = wheels;
return this;
}
public Vehicle2 build(){
return new Vehicle2(this);
}
}
public Vehicle2(Builder<? extends Vehicle2> builder){
Vehicle2 v = new Vehicle2();
v.type = builder.getType();
v.wheels = builder.getWheels();
}
public Vehicle2(){
}
public static void main(String[] args) {
//This builds a car with 4 wheels
Vehicle2 car = new Vehicle2.CarBuilder().createVehicle().addWheels(4).build();
//THis builds a Truck with 10 wheels
Vehicle2 truck = new Vehicle2.TruckBuilder().createVehicle().addWheels(10).build();
}
}